The Nelson class were battleships of the British Royal Navy built shortly following the Washington Naval Treaty in 1922. Because of the limitations of the treaty the structure of the ships had to be revised, which resulted in unusual design considerations.
Two ships of the class were produced, both named after famous British admirals: HMS Rodney and HMS Nelson .
The Battle of Jutland had shown the value of firepower and protection over speed and maneuverability. Admiral Fisher's dictum that "speed is armor" had been tested in battle, and had been decisively disproved. Thickness of armor and weight of shell were now seen as the keys to naval victory.
The next generation of British warships were to incorporate this lesson. After the War the Admiralty drew up plans for massive, heavily armored battlecruisers and battleships, far larger and stronger than all previous vessels. They would carry 16 and 18 in (406 and 457 mm) guns and would be the most powerful vessels afloat.
However, development was abruptly halted by the signature of the Washington Naval Treaty in 1922.
The Treaty limit of 35,000 tons and 16 in (406 mm) guns killed the projected super-warships, and the Royal Navy was forced to scale down its designs. The result of this compromise was the Nelson Class of battleships. These were well-armored and defended (nine 16 in (406 mm) guns in three turrets), but light and small enough to conform to the Treaty terms. (Navy men referred to this as the "Cherry Tree Class", because it had been "cut down by Washington").
The need to increase firepower and armor, while keeping weight low, resulted in a radical new warship design:
In order to reduce weight of armor, all the primary gun turrets were mounted on the foredeck. They could then be served by a single magazine, instead of the two necessitated by traditional designs. The secondary guns were all located near the stern for the same reason. The engines and superstructure were also placed aft in order to balance the heavy weight of the primary armament.
This new and unusual design had several serious flaws.
Despite the rear location of the superstructure, the center of gravity of the ships was still too far forward. This caused maneuverability problems in high wind: the superstructure acted as a sail, causing the ships to "weathervane" when steaming at low speeds. This was a particularly dangerous problem in crowded harbors, and the ships were notoriously difficult to dock and embark.
In consequence of this, HMS Nelson and her sister Rodney were sarcastically nicknamed Nelsol and Rodnol by the Royal Navy - their maneuverability problems and silhouettes reminded Navy men of oil tankers, not battleships. (Royal Navy oilers were always given names ending in "ol".)
The closeness of the primary turrets to each other was also a danger to the structural integrity of the ships. The crews were warned to never fire all the 16 in (406 mm) guns at the same time, because this would damage the deck - clearly, a serious handicap on a fighting ship.
Another complication was the size of the forward gun deck. This area had to be kept clear of obstructions since any structures located there would be destroyed by the blast of the guns. However, this left a very large area of the deck where anti-aircraft guns could not be sited. The problem was partially solved by mounting AA guns on top of the turrets, though air defense remained a serious weakness with these vessels throughout their careers.
In theory the "all-forward" design reduced the danger of an enemy "crossing the T" of the ship, since all the main guns could be brought to bear on forward targets. However, this advantage was offset by the awkward location of the third ("X") turret. For structural reasons it was mounted lower on deck than the second ("B"), which severely limited its forward field of fire. This was bad enough, but "X" could also not fire in the aft quarters without damaging the superstructure. (The bridge was a particularly unpleasant place to be when firing on distant stern targets.)
When the Washington Treaty lapsed in 1936 the Royal Navy abandoned the "all-forward" arrangement and returned with relief to traditional designs.
Despite these difficulties both Nelson and Rodney had successful careers during World War II, the latter vessel helping to sink KMS Bismarck in 1941 (although the guncrews ignored engineers' instructions during the battle, and inflicted more damage on their own ship than Bismarck did.)
| Nelson-class battleship |
| Nelson | Rodney |
List of battleships of the Royal Navy |